my top ten:

1. Peyton Manning, IND
2. Tom Brady, NE
3. Drew Brees, NO
4. Kurt Warner, ARI
5. Brett Farve, MIN
6. Tony Romo, DAL
7. Aaron Rodgers, GB
8. Ben Roethlisberger, PIT
9. Phillip Rivers, SD
10. Matt Schaub, HOU
(hon. mention: McNabb, Eli, Palmer)

I think Schaub should be on every top ten list. I made a big stink about Carson Palmer earlier, but he really fell off hard this year.